Hildegard Berube

Hildegard Berube

Hildegard Berube

  • ,
  • Education & Training
  • Member Since: 20 Nov 2026

How an interim CFO reviews expense and card policies: 3 checks

Many first-time founders assume an interim chief financial officer (CFO) starts with forecasts and investor decks. In practice, the first thing to examine is how an interim CFO reviews expense and card policies, because loose spending rules hide the true cost of running the business. When nobody clearly owns approvals, money leaves without a documented reason, and the books stay late and hard to trust.


Why spending rules come before forecasts in the first weeks


When a company loses its finance leader, the people left behind often want the new person to say what comes next: raise money, fix the forecast, or prepare for a buyer. Those goals make sense, but the early work usually looks plainer. The first weeks go to finding out what the company actually spends, who spends it, and whether anyone checks. Think of it as reading the fuel gauge before planning the road trip.


A few terms help here. An interim CFO is a senior finance leader hired for a set period, often to cover a gap such as a departure or a leave. A fractional CFO works for a company part-time on an ongoing basis. A controller usually runs the accounting team, the monthly close, and the internal records. Outsourced accounting means an outside firm handles bookkeeping or parts of it. Titles overlap in practice, so the job description matters more than the label.


Spending is a good starting point because it is the most recent and most testable part of the financial picture. Bank and card statements show what actually left the account. A forecast is a guess about the future, and a budget is a plan, but a statement is a record. If the record is messy, every forecast built on it inherits the mess.


Many owners believe that having an expense policy means spending is under control. A policy is a written set of rules about who can buy what, what needs approval, and which documents are required. Having one on paper is not the same as following it. In a typical small company, the policy was written during a busy month, shared once by email, and then forgotten. The interim CFO's first question is simple: does what happens match what is written?


Consider a hypothetical company in New York City with a small team and no full-time finance executive. The founder has a corporate card, two managers have cards, and a shared card sits with the office administrator. Nobody has looked at the statements in months. The interim CFO does not start with the revenue plan. The first task is to list every card, every spending category, and every person who can approve a purchase.


This review does not tell you whether a particular purchase was wise. It tells you whether the company knows what it spends and why. That difference matters when a lender or investor asks questions. Nothing in this review guarantees a loan, an investment, or a sale, but it removes one common reason those conversations stall.


Check one: who can spend, who approves, and where the limits sit


The first check looks at authority, meaning the permission to spend money and the permission to approve it. An approval limit is the amount above which a second person must sign off. A card limit is the most a card can be charged in a set period. Both ideas are simple, yet small companies often set them once and never revisit them, so a limit written for last year's team may not fit today's travel and software needs.


Start by listing every card, every bank account with payment rights, and every person who can submit a bill or expense. Then compare that list with the written policy. Many companies find a card nobody remembers opening, or a former employee who still has access. Think of it as checking the keys to a building: you want to know who holds one, and whether the old ones were ever returned.






Read the table as a question for each row. Who is allowed to spend? Who signs off? Who checks the approval later? In many small companies, the founder approves their own spending, which in practice means nobody approves it. That is one of the most common gaps an interim CFO finds in a first review. It is rarely a sign of bad faith. It is what happens when a company grows faster than its rules.


The underlying idea is called separation of duties. The person who spends money should not also be the only person who approves it and records it. The rule is easy to state and easy to skip on a team of three people doing five jobs. An interim CFO startup in New York City CFO usually cannot add headcount, but can split the tasks: one person approves, another reconciles the card statement, and a third receives the monthly summary.


Accounting software can help enforce this. Systems such as QuickBooks, NetSuite, and Sage Intacct can route bills and expenses for approval, though what is available depends on the plan and on how the system was set up. Ask your bookkeeper or the vendor what the system actually enforces. Do not assume a setting exists because a product page mentions it.


A simple sequence for this check looks like this:



  1. Export a complete list of cards, bank logins, and people who can submit expenses.

  2. Compare each limit with the written policy, and note any card with no named owner.

  3. Confirm that approval limits match how the team actually spends.

  4. Identify who approves the founder's own spending, and move that review to someone else.

  5. Write down each change, the date, and the reason for it.


Check two: whether every charge has a receipt, a business reason, and a category


The second check asks whether each charge can be explained. A card statement shows the merchant and the amount. It does not show why the money was spent, whether it served the business, or where it belongs in the books. For every transaction, the check connects three things: a receipt, a written business reason, and a category from the company's chart of accounts, which is the list of categories, such as travel, software, or meals, that the books use to sort spending.


What counts as a usable receipt?


A usable receipt shows the vendor, the date, the amount, and enough detail to know what was bought. A photo of a card slip with a total and no line items often fails. A receipt that lives only in an employee's inbox or phone is hard to find during month-end review, and a payment confirmation may not show what the business actually received. The policy should say what counts and how long to keep it. Many companies require a receipt above a set amount and a written explanation for any charge without one. Those rules are choices the company makes, not standards the interim CFO imposes.


Why the business reason is a separate step


A receipt proves that money changed hands. A business reason explains why it was a business expense. One sentence is usually enough: which client the lunch was for, which conference the flight covered, or which team uses the software seat. Without that sentence, a reviewer later has to guess, and guessing is how personal purchases slip into the books. Think of the reason as the label on a box. The box might be fine, but nobody knows what is inside until someone writes it down.


Reimbursements need their own look. When an employee pays out of pocket and the company repays them, the repayment should follow a documented rule. Internal Revenue Service (IRS) rules describe a structure called an accountable plan, which generally requires a business connection, documentation, and the return of any extra money. Whether a company's arrangement qualifies is a question for a tax professional, not for the person writing the policy. An interim CFO can make sure the process produces the records a tax professional would ask for.


Categories are where many reports go wrong. If every card charge lands in a catch-all line called miscellaneous, the monthly report says little about where the money went. Software subscriptions, travel, and client meals may each need their own category so that the forecast can show them separately. The interim CFO usually recodes a sample of past transactions and then sets a rule for new ones. Recoding is not an accusation. It makes the numbers easier to explain to a board, a lender, or a future buyer.


A simple sequence for this check:



  1. Pull a recent set of card and reimbursement transactions.

  2. Match each one to a receipt, and note any that lack one.

  3. Confirm that each transaction has a short business reason recorded in the system.

  4. Check that the category fits the actual purpose, not only the merchant name.

  5. Send missing items to the person who spent the money, with the deadline the policy sets.


Check three: whether exceptions are reviewed and the policy is enforced each month


The third check asks whether the rules still work after the first few weeks. A policy nobody enforces is only a suggestion. Enforcement means someone looks at exceptions, which are charges that break a rule, and acts on them. An interim CFO usually sets a monthly review, because a monthly cycle is easy for a small team to keep and early enough to catch problems before they show up as surprises at year-end.


A monthly review tends to surface a few recurring exceptions:



  • receipts that arrived after the policy deadline

  • purchases split into smaller charges to stay under an approval limit

  • subscriptions that continue after the person who needed them has left

  • personal purchases made on a company card

  • cards still active for someone who no longer works at the company


Split purchases deserve a closer look. Suppose an approval limit is set at a certain amount and an employee buys the same item in two charges, each just under it. Nobody needs to assume bad intent. The rule is still being avoided, and the review should say so plainly. The fix is usually a small change, such as a lower limit for that category or a second approver for that merchant, rather than a lecture.


Offboarding is another point where controls quietly fail. When someone leaves, the company should cancel their cards, remove their access to the expense system, and look for recurring charges tied to them. A former employee's subscription can keep billing for months if nobody owns the list. An interim CFO often finds these charges on the first statement review, because nobody connected the departure with the payment.


A review also needs an escalation path. Decide in advance who receives each exception, how quickly they need to act, and what happens if the person responsible does not respond. Small companies often skip this step, so every exception becomes an awkward conversation between two people. A written path turns it into routine, and routine is what keeps the check working after the interim period ends.


Keep the review short enough that people will actually read it. A one-page summary of open exceptions, owners, and dates is usually more useful than a long memo. The goal is not to catch every small mistake. The goal is to make sure the same mistake does not repeat and that someone outside the spending chain has seen the pattern.


How the three checks feed cash visibility and the forecast


Cash visibility means knowing, at any given time, how much money is in the bank, what is coming in, and what is going out. Cash flow is the movement of that money over time. A company can look healthy on paper and still run short of cash, because bills come due before customers pay. The three checks matter here because they make the outflows, the spending that leaves the account, accurate and timely.


A forecast is a projection of future cash flow, and it is only as good as its inputs. If card spending is recorded late, the forecast will show more cash than the company really has. If subscriptions are unknown, the forecast misses a steady drain. Cleaner categories let an interim CFO separate fixed costs, such as rent and software, from variable costs, such as travel and client meals, and show how each one moves over time.


Working capital is the cash tied up in day-to-day operations, such as unpaid customer invoices and bills you have not paid yet. Spending controls affect it indirectly. When approvals are slow or receipts are late, bills can be paid late or twice, and the cash picture gets harder to read. A monthly spending review is one of the simpler ways to keep that picture steady.


Many companies track a few key performance indicators (KPIs), which are measures that show how the business is doing. A common one is burn rate, the speed at which cash leaves the company each month. A burn rate only means something if the spending behind it is correct. An interim CFO startup in New York City CFO may use cleaned categories to calculate that number and then explain it in plain language to founders, lenders, or a board. The number is a tool for decisions, not a verdict on the company.


Here is a hypothetical example. A company pays for software through several cards, and its monthly report lumps everything under office costs. After the review, the software charges move to their own category, and two unused subscriptions are cancelled. The forecast now shows a clearer monthly outflow, and the founder can see how much the cancellations remove from it. The actual amount depends on prices and usage that change over time, so treat this as an illustration, not a promise.


Expect the first forecast after the review to look less tidy than the one before. Cleaner data often reveals costs that were hidden. That is a sign the checks are working, not a sign that something failed. No review guarantees better results, financing, or a sale. What it can do is make the numbers something you can explain without guessing.


What the checks look like for a New York City company with a small finance team


New York City companies have spending patterns that make these checks more specific. Teams may travel between offices, client sites, and events. Staff may use ride services, buy meals during late work, or pay for software tools that serve several departments at once. A policy written with a generic company in mind can miss these habits, so the rules should name the categories the team actually uses.


Think about a hypothetical nonprofit in New York City with a part-time bookkeeper, a finance committee that meets quarterly, and staff who buy supplies on personal cards. The organization is preparing for a grant renewal, and the funder will ask for clean records. The interim CFO starts by listing who holds cards, then rewrites the reimbursement steps so that receipts are required before repayment.


For an organization like this, the review focuses on documentation and approval rather than on new systems. The interim CFO may recommend a shared folder for receipts, a one-page policy, and a monthly exception list for the finance committee. These steps mostly take attention rather than new tools, and a permanent staff member can carry them forward later. The interim CFO's job is to set the rhythm, not to run it forever.


A small startup in the same city faces a different version of the problem. Founders often pay for things personally during a fast-moving month and then want to be reimbursed quickly. Investors may also ask for clear monthly reports, so the review concentrates on making the card statements and the books match at month-end. The first task is to find out whether the founders' own spending is reviewed by someone other than themselves.


Boundaries matter in a review like this. The interim CFO should not take over bank logins without written authority from the company's owners, and should not decide tax treatment alone. Those decisions belong to the people who hold the accounts and, for tax questions, to a qualified tax professional. A review that stays within its role is easier to trust and easier to hand over when a permanent person arrives.


What the checks cannot fix and when a controller or outside accountant may be a better fit


These three checks have limits, and it helps to say them out loud. A review of expense and card policies does not repair a bookkeeping system that was set up incorrectly, does not replace a controller who runs the monthly close, and does not settle questions about tax or employment. It also does not decide whether a purchase was a good idea. Those are different jobs, and different roles handle them.


The roles are easy to confuse, so a comparison helps. Each one covers different work and fits a different problem.






Some signals mean the company needs more than these checks. Recurring duplicate payments, unexplained gaps between the bank and the books, and reports that take weeks to produce all point to a system problem. When you see them, the review should stop and the issue should go to the people who can fix the system. Do not try to investigate suspected fraud or serious irregularities yourself. Bring in legal counsel and an outside accountant, and keep a record of what was found and when.


Expectations should match the scope. An interim period can give a company continuity in financial leadership and a clearer picture of its spending, which can help when it approaches investors, lenders, or buyers. It cannot promise a funding round, a loan approval, or a sale. Those depend on many factors outside the finance function, including the market, the product, and the people on the other side of the table.


When you decide whether to bring in outside help, ask what problem you are solving. If the answer is a missing finance leader, an interim CFO may fit. If the answer is daily bookkeeping that keeps falling behind, a controller or an outsourced firm may fit better. If the answer is a longer-term plan, a fractional CFO may be the next step. Matching the role to the problem prevents the common mistake of hiring a senior title for junior work.


What to confirm with a professional before you decide


Before you commit to an interim CFO or any finance support, ask for specifics. Vague promises about streamlining finance are not enough. A useful conversation covers the scope of the work, the handoff plan, and who is responsible for what. The questions below are a starting list, not a replacement for your own judgment or your advisers' advice.



  1. Which written policies will you review first, and which changes will you make only after asking me?

  2. Who will hold admin access to our cards and accounting system, and how will that access be removed when the engagement ends?

  3. How will you test each month whether receipts and business reasons are complete?

  4. What does the handoff to a permanent finance leader look like, and which documents will I receive?

  5. Which decisions need my approval, and which need a tax professional or an attorney?

  6. What is outside the scope, such as tax filings, payroll, or audits?

  7. Can you share references from companies of similar size and industry, and may I speak with them?


Ask for the answers in writing. A short written scope protects both sides and makes it easier to see whether the work is being done. Compare the proposed arrangement with the problem you named at the start. If the scope does not match the problem, the fit is wrong, however polished the proposal looks.


Check the person as well as the firm. Ask what experience they have with companies of your size, stage, and industry, and ask how you could verify it. Any credential or certification should come with evidence you can review. Be careful with claims of guaranteed results, fixed timelines, or specific savings. A responsible advisor cannot promise those before seeing your records.


Finally, confirm with a qualified tax professional or attorney any question about reimbursements, personal spending on company cards, or how payments to employees are treated. A finance review can surface these issues, but it should not settle them alone. Keep the answers in your own files, with dates, so the next person who takes over can see what was decided and why.


Details

Phone 2062170472
Email Address hildegard_berube53@flipz.top
Gender Male
Salary 12 - 96
Address 98119

Cookies

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website.

Accept