Rickie Dixson

Rickie Dixson

Rickie Dixson

  • ,
  • Security & Safety
  • Member Since: 20 Nov 2026

Risks of overstating EBITDA adjustments to buyers: a checklist

The main risks of overstating EBITDA adjustments to buyers are not just a lower price. A buyer who finds one add-back that cannot be traced will often re-check every other line, and the deal slows or changes shape. Most of these problems start with a normal habit: presenting earnings in the best light. The checklist below shows where that habit goes too far.



Why buyers test every add-back before they trust the number


Buyers rarely accept EBITDA at face value. They start from reported net income, add back interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization, and then review each adjustment the seller proposes on top of that base. Every adjustment asks the buyer to believe something: that a cost will not return, or that an unusual income item is safe to exclude. The buyer's task is to decide which of those beliefs can be checked and which can only be accepted on trust.


The reason for this care is simple. Many offers are tied to a multiple of earnings, so each dollar of added earnings moves the price. A buyer does not need the seller to be dishonest to become cautious. One unexplained line is often enough to request the general ledger, the invoices and the contracts behind the whole adjustment list. Once that request is made, the buyer is no longer reading the seller's story. The buyer is building their own.


From the seller's side, most adjustments look reasonable when taken one at a time. The owner paid a personal expense through the company. A lawsuit ended. A product line was shut down in the middle of the year. Each story may be accurate. The problem begins when the story is stronger than the paperwork behind it, and the seller expects the buyer to take the explanation without asking for more.


In my view, the most useful question for a seller is not "can this be added back?" but "can I show a buyer why it should be added back, in a form they can test without calling me?" That shift changes how the schedule gets built. It pushes the seller to find the invoice, the lease or the board minute before the number is presented, instead of after a question comes back. It also explains why a shorter, well-supported list often moves faster than a long list of items that depend on explanation.


The trade-off is between the headline number and the certainty of the deal. A longer list may look generous, but each extra line gives the buyer another place to stop and ask. A shorter list may leave some value on the table, but it is easier to defend. It depends on how much the buyer already trusts the business, and on whether the seller expects a second round of questions. Sellers who have been through a process before tend to weigh these points differently from those who have not.



Which adjustments buyers question first


Not every add-back receives the same scrutiny. Owner compensation, one-time costs and revenue timing tend to draw the most questions, because each of them can move earnings a long way and each depends on a judgment that a buyer cannot see from the outside. The following areas are where a careful buyer usually starts, and where a seller should expect to spend the most time with the paperwork.


Owner compensation comes first in most reviews. When an owner pays themselves above or below what a replacement would earn, the adjustment changes the picture of the business. The buyer will ask what a manager doing the owner's job would cost, whether the owner's relationships with customers or suppliers would transfer, and how the company would operate after closing. Vague answers to those questions usually hurt more than the adjustment itself.


One-time costs are the second area. Legal settlements, relocation expenses, a flood repair or a system migration can be real non-recurring items. Buyers accept them more readily when the event is clearly unusual and documented from start to finish. They push back when similar costs show up in several years under different labels, because the pattern suggests the cost is part of normal operations. The same invoice can be credible in one year and doubtful in three.


Revenue timing is the third area, and it is often the most technical. If a company recognizes revenue earlier than its contracts support, an adjustment that moves income between periods can look like earnings that were never fully earned in the period being sold. Under ASC 606, the timing of revenue depends on when performance obligations are satisfied, so a seller who proposes a timing change needs a clear basis tied to the contract terms, not a general sense that the work was done.


Related-party arrangements form a fourth group. Rent paid to an owner's property, management fees charged to a family entity, and shared staff between companies all change earnings in ways a buyer will want to see. If the rent is below market, an adjustment to a market rent may be appropriate, but only if the lease is documented and the buyer can see what a new lease would require. Discretionary spending, such as travel or marketing, belongs here too. Those cuts can be real, yet the buyer will ask whether the spending supported the business or reflected a personal choice, and whether the cut would affect future revenue.



Where a reasonable adjustment becomes an overstatement


A line separates judgment from wishful thinking. An adjustment crosses that line when it removes a cost the business will keep paying after the sale, or when it adds income the business has not earned under its own contracts and policies. The difficulty is that the line is not always visible to the person who drew it. Owners who live with the business every day often see a cost as temporary because they expect it to end, even when the ledger shows it has been there for years.


One common pattern is a recurring cost presented as one-time. Consider a company that buys a certain type of consulting service every year and books it under a new description each time. If the seller adds back only the most recent invoice, the buyer will compare several years of the general ledger and see the same vendor, the same purpose and the same timing. Once the buyer sees the pattern, they may reject the add-back and question the rest of the list, which costs the seller more credibility than the original line was worth.


A second pattern is normalizing a cost to the level of a good year rather than the level the business actually runs at. If a seller reduces marketing spending to a figure that reflects a quiet period, the buyer will ask how the company plans to grow without that spending, and whether the growth assumed in the sale story requires the spending the adjustment removed. A normalization that cannot be squared with the forecast invites the buyer to build a different forecast of their own.


Here is a hypothetical case, built only to show the mechanics. Suppose a company pays legal fees in one year and labels them as a settlement. The next year it pays a similar amount to outside counsel for a dispute with a different party, and books it as professional services. The seller adds back both amounts as non-recurring. A buyer who reads both invoices will likely see the same law firm, the same kind of work and the same level of cost. The buyer may remove both add-backs, and may also ask whether other legal costs have been treated the same way.


The simplest test is to imagine explaining each adjustment to a stranger who has no reason to trust you. If the adjustment still makes sense after you show the ledger, the contract and a short memo, it is ready. If the answer depends on the buyer taking your word for it, the adjustment is not yet defensible, and it is better to withdraw it or support it before the number is shared. The reason is not that buyers assume bad faith. It is that they cannot verify what they cannot see.



Building an adjustment schedule a buyer can trace


The schedule is a working document, not a summary for the cover page. Each line needs a plain description, the amount, the period it applies to, the account or accounts where the amount sits in the ledger, and a reference to the records that support it. A buyer's analyst should be able to pick up the schedule, follow each reference and reach the same figure without asking the seller for a walkthrough.


Traceability depends on the accounting system. A company using QuickBooks, NetSuite or Sage Intacct can usually export transaction detail that matches the schedule line by line. The tool matters less than the discipline behind it. If the same vendor payment is split across two accounts, or a reclassification was made in a spreadsheet and never posted to the books, the buyer will find the gap. A good habit is to filter the ledger for each adjustment and confirm that the total matches before the schedule leaves the company.


For each non-routine item, write a short memo. The memo should say what happened, why the seller believes it will not recur, and what would change the conclusion if it did. Long narrative tends to hide the key facts, so short and specific is better. A memo that says a supplier relationship ended on a given basis and that no replacement cost is expected is easier to test than a page of background about the market.


The adjusted figure should walk from the reported figure with every change visible. Start with the reported earnings measure, list each adjustment in order, and show a running total. If a buyer rebuilds the number and gets a different result, the reason should be clear from the schedule itself. Keep the reconciliation tied to the reported financial statements, so the buyer can see where each adjustment sits in the accounts that were audited, reviewed or prepared under the company's usual process.


Finally, date each version of the schedule and record who changed what. Buyers often ask questions well after the first draft, and the answers should come from the same file the seller already shared. Creating a new spreadsheet in response to a question makes the process look improvised. A simple version log, kept with the schedule, helps the seller answer quickly and shows that the figures have been reviewed rather than rebuilt under pressure.



How interim, fractional, controller and outsourced accounting roles split this work


Different finance roles handle the adjustment schedule in different ways, and the difference matters when a sale is on the horizon. The question to ask is not which role is best in general. It is who will own the judgment behind each adjustment, who will maintain the records that support it and who will answer the buyer when a question comes back months later.


An interim CFO is usually brought in to fill a gap in financial leadership for a defined period. When a sale is the goal, the interim CFO may build the schedule, make the judgment calls and prepare the owner to defend them. The trade-off is that the role may end before the sale does, which makes the handoff to a permanent finance leader or a continuing advisor an important part of the plan.


A fractional CFO works part-time over a longer period. This role often suits a company that wants ongoing strategic finance, including forecasting, board or investor reporting and preparation for a transaction. Because the involvement continues, the fractional CFO can keep the schedule current as the business changes. It depends on how much time the company actually needs, and whether the relationship is structured so that the work does not depend on one person's availability.


A controller focuses on the accounting close, financial reporting and internal controls. In many companies the controller supplies the records that support each adjustment, while the owner or CFO makes the judgment. A controller is often the right place to start when the records are the main weakness, because a schedule built on unreliable close processes will fail in diligence regardless of who drafted it.


Outsourced accounting covers bookkeeping, transaction processing and often the monthly close. It can provide a clean base of records, which helps traceability. It does not usually replace the judgment about which items are truly non-recurring. That judgment still needs an owner inside the company or an advisor who can speak for the numbers. The table below compares the four roles on the points that matter most for a sale.


Interim CFOFilling a gap in financial leadership for a defined periodThe interim CFO Startup In New York City CFO, with the owner's sign-offUseful when the sale must be prepared without a permanent finance leader in place
Fractional CFOPart-time strategic finance over a longer periodThe fractional CFO, working with the owner and any controllerUseful when the company wants ongoing support through preparation and handoff
ControllerAccounting close, reporting and internal controlsUsually the owner or CFO, with the controller supplying the recordsUseful when the records themselves are the main weakness
Outsourced accountingBookkeeping, transaction processing and often the monthly closeUsually the company's leadership, with the provider supplying dataUseful for a clean base of records, though judgment still needs an owner

Read the table as a starting point for a conversation, not a verdict. A company may need two of these roles at once, such as a controller for the close and a fractional CFO for the transaction. The point is to decide in advance who holds each responsibility, because buyers ask about it directly. Whatever the structure, the arrangement should be written down so that the adjustment judgment does not disappear when the person who made it moves on.



A checklist to run before any adjusted number leaves the company


The checklist below is meant to be used by the owner or finance lead before the adjusted figure is shared with anyone outside the company. Each question tests a different weakness. A schedule can pass most of them and still fail one, so it is worth answering every question in writing rather than assuming the answer.



  1. Can each adjustment be traced to ledger entries that a buyer can filter and total?

  2. Has a similar cost appeared in earlier years, and if so, what makes this instance different?

  3. Would the business need to replace the owner's work, and does the schedule account for that replacement?

  4. Does the revenue timing match the contract terms and the performance obligations behind them?

  5. Are related-party terms documented, disclosed, and set at a level a buyer can compare to the market?

  6. Could the seller explain each line without reading the memo aloud from start to finish?


The first question is the most mechanical, and it is where many schedules break down. A total that cannot be reproduced from the ledger is a warning sign, even if the underlying cost is real. The second question asks the seller to look backward. Buyers will look at prior years, so the seller should too, before the buyer does. If the answer is that the cost is different because the reason changed, the memo should say how, with the records to prove it.


The third and fourth questions tend to be the ones owners underestimate. Replacing an owner who runs the sales relationships, approves the pricing and signs the contracts may cost more than the owner's pay suggests, and the schedule should show whether that work was considered. Revenue timing is similar. A small change in when income is recorded can change the earnings figure in a way that is hard to explain without the contract in hand.


The last two questions test readiness rather than arithmetic. Related-party terms are often the easiest to document after the fact and the hardest to defend without support, so they belong on the list. The final question is a practical test of whether the seller understands the numbers well enough to speak for them. A schedule that only the bookkeeper understands is not ready for a buyer, however accurate it may be.


It depends on the company how many of these questions will produce work. A business with clean records and a small number of adjustments may pass quickly. A business with several years of inconsistent treatment may need to revisit the schedule from the beginning. The checklist does not promise a particular result. It only tells the seller which parts of the schedule are likely to be questioned, so that the answers exist before the question arrives.



What happens in due diligence when an adjustment does not hold


When a buyer rejects an adjustment, the usual result is a lower earnings figure, not the end of the transaction. Still, that change can carry more weight than its size suggests. The buyer will recalculate the offer, and the seller will need to explain why the original number was different. The more lines that fail, the more the conversation shifts from the business itself to the reliability of the numbers behind it.


One consequence is a reopened price. A buyer may agree to terms in principle and then revisit the figure after diligence turns up unsupported adjustments. Sellers who prepared the schedule carefully tend to have fewer of these surprises, because the buyer's findings match what the seller already disclosed. Sellers who relied on the headline number often find that every new question adds more back-and-forth and makes the next negotiation harder.


Another consequence is the time and attention the team must spend. Answering questions about a schedule takes hours from people who are also running the business. That work can distract from operations at the moment performance matters most to the buyer. A seller who anticipated the questions can answer them from a prepared file, which keeps the team focused and limits the chance that a rushed answer creates a new problem.


A seller can also withdraw an adjustment before the buyer finds it. The trade-off is that the headline number looks smaller, and the seller gives up some value they believed was legitimate. In return, the rest of the schedule carries more weight, because the buyer sees a seller who is willing to reduce a claim rather than defend a weak one. That approach does not suit every case, and it depends on whether the withdrawn item is central to the sale story.


No preparation guarantees a sale, a price or a particular outcome. Buyers differ in how much they trust a seller's numbers, and market conditions, financing and the company's own performance all affect the result. Experienced advisors can help organize the schedule and anticipate questions, but they cannot control the buyer. The most a well-prepared seller can expect is a fair and efficient review of numbers that can be checked.



Worked example: reviewing two add-backs for a hypothetical software company before a sale conversation


Consider a hypothetical software company in New York City with a small team, an owner who handles key customer relationships and no full-time finance executive. The owner is considering a sale and has asked an outside finance advisor to help prepare the adjusted earnings figure. The company's reporting is monthly, but the close takes longer than it should, and the owner believes two items should be added back before the figure is shared with any potential buyer.


The first item is owner compensation. The owner pays themselves less than a replacement general manager would likely cost, based on the duties they perform. The advisor asks the owner to list those duties, including customer escalations, contract approvals and hiring decisions. The schedule then shows the estimated cost of a replacement, which lowers the proposed adjustment. The adjustment is still made, but it is smaller, and the memo explains which duties would need to be covered and how.


The second item is a legal cost. The company paid outside counsel for a contract dispute that ended in the prior year, and the owner wants to add the full amount back as non-recurring. The advisor pulls the ledger for the past three years and finds smaller legal payments in two of them, recorded under the same vendor. The advisor flags the pattern. Rather than drop the add-back, they split it: the portion tied to the specific dispute is kept with the contract file and the closing correspondence, and the routine legal costs stay in earnings.


With the two items reviewed, the schedule is rebuilt from the reported figure. Each line references the ledger account, the period and a short memo. The advisor runs a filter for each adjustment and confirms that the totals match. The owner reads the schedule aloud and tries to explain each line without the memo in hand. Two lines are harder to explain than the owner expected, so the memo for the compensation item is expanded to name the specific duties.


The outcome of this exercise is not a promise. The schedule is more defensible, and the owner knows which numbers can be checked and which depend on judgment. A buyer may still disagree with the compensation estimate or question the legal split, and the price could change for reasons unrelated to the schedule. What the owner gains is a clearer position for the conversation, a file that answers the likely questions and a list of open items to resolve before the next draft.


For a company in a similar position, the practical next step is to choose one adjustment and test it against the checklist before adding any others. Trace it to the ledger, check earlier years, and write a short memo that a stranger could follow. If it survives that test, the rest of the schedule can be built the same way. If it does not, it is better to find out now than during a buyer's review.


Details

Phone 193726834
Email Address rickie_dixson65@shrinkr.top
Gender Female
Salary 22 - 78
Address 91700

Cookies

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website.

Accept